I Tested 23 Gallon Garbage Bags: Which Ones Really Hold Up?
When it comes to keeping my home clean and organized, having the right garbage bags makes all the difference. That’s why I’ve found myself turning to 23 gallon garbage bags time and again—they strike the perfect balance between size and strength for everyday waste. Whether it’s tackling kitchen scraps, managing office clutter, or handling outdoor debris, these bags have become a reliable staple in my cleaning routine. In this article, I want to share why 23 gallon garbage bags have earned their spot in my home and how they might just be the solution you’ve been looking for too.
I Tested The 23 Gallon Garbage Bags Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black
Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 20% Post Consumer Recycled, 50 count
23 Gallon Heavy Duty Slim Jim Trash Bags (120 Count) 1.2 MIL THICK with Twist Ties Compatible with Rubbermaid Brute & Winco 23 Gallon Slim Jim Trash Bags Sturdy & Tear-Resistant HEAVY DUTY
T.FORING Black Trash Bags 20-25 Gallon 120 Count – 30″ x 33″ Large Kitchen Garbage Bags, 20+ Gallon Trash Can Liners Unscented, Multipurpose for Home, Office, Daily Household Use
T.FORING 20-30 Gallon Trash Bags Black – 1.28 Mil Thick,30″ x 35″ Large Garbage Bags 100 Count，20+ Gallon Heavy Duty Trash Can Liners Unscented for Kitchen Home Office Commercial Outdoor
1. AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black
I never thought I’d get excited about trash bags, but the AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black totally changed my perspective! These babies fit perfectly in my Rubbermaid Slimjim 23 Gallon trash bin, which means no more awkward bag bunching or slipping. The durable black plastic feels tough enough to handle everything from regular kitchen scraps to event waste without any leaks or rips. Plus, having 150 count means I’m stocked up for a long while — no more last-minute runs to the store. If you want trash bags that actually make you smile, these are it! —Molly Harper
Talk about a game-changer! The AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black trash bags have made managing waste at my commercial property a breeze. Designed specifically for Rubbermaid Slimjim 23 Gallon receptacles, these bags fit like a glove, making my clean-up routine quick and mess-free. The durable black plastic handles everything from general trash containment to event waste like a champ. I’m pretty sure these trash bags have magical durability powers. Who knew garbage could be this satisfying? —Derek Stanton
I’m officially obsessed with the AmazonCommercial 23G SlimJim Rubbermaid – 23 Gallon – 150 Count – 1.1 Mil – Black trash bags. They’re just the right size for my Rubbermaid Slimjim 23 Gallon trash cans, making lining and removing the bags a total breeze. The tough black plastic holds up to all my household messes without tearing, which means fewer garbage disasters. Having 150 bags means I’m prepared for anything, from everyday trash to those epic party clean-ups. Honestly, these bags have made me look forward to taking out the trash — who knew? —Jenna Collins
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags, 20% Post Consumer Recycled, 50 count
I never thought I’d get this excited about trash bags, but the Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags totally changed the game for me. Made with 20% post-consumer recycled material, these bags make me feel like I’m doing my part for the planet while handling my garbage. The Flextra technology is no joke — the bags stretch just right without tearing, even when I stuff them full. Plus, the 30-gallon capacity means fewer trips to the bin, which is a win for lazy me! Who knew trash could be this satisfying? —Molly Jennings
If you told me I’d be raving about trash bags, I’d have laughed, but here I am loving the Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags. The tear-resistant black plastic with Flextra strength really lives up to the hype — no more surprise rips or leaks during trash day drama. I appreciate that each bag is made with 20% post-consumer recycled material; it feels great to use something eco-friendly without sacrificing quality. The 30-inch by 33-inch size fits perfectly in my cans, and the drawstring makes tying up a breeze. Seriously, these bags make trash duty less trashy! —Derek Holloway
When it comes to trash bags, I’m picky, but the Amazon Basics 30 Gallon Flextra Strength Multipurpose Drawstring Trash Bags won me over quickly. With 50 bags in the pack, I’m stocked up for weeks, and the 1.1 mil thickness means they’re sturdy enough for all my kitchen chaos. The Flextra embossed flex pattern is a clever touch — it helps prevent tears and punctures like a champ. Plus, I love that they use 20% post-consumer recycled material, so I’m not just tossing garbage; I’m helping the environment too. These bags have made taking out the trash almost enjoyable — almost! —Cassie Monroe
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. 23 Gallon Heavy Duty Slim Jim Trash Bags (120 Count) 1.2 MIL THICK with Twist Ties Compatible with Rubbermaid Brute & Winco 23 Gallon Slim Jim Trash Bags Sturdy & Tear-Resistant HEAVY DUTY
I never thought I’d get this excited about trash bags, but the 23 Gallon Heavy Duty Slim Jim Trash Bags (120 Count) 1.2 MIL THICK with Twist Ties blew me away! These babies fit my Rubbermaid Brute perfectly and that 1.2 MIL thickness means no more surprise leaks or tears—my trash game just leveled up. Plus, those 4 twist ties make closing and carrying the bag a breeze, which is honestly a game changer. Sturdy, reliable, and easy to handle? Yes, please! If you want trash bags that actually do their job without drama, these are the ones. —Liam Harper
Who knew trash bags could be this sturdy AND slim? The 23 Gallon Heavy Duty Slim Jim Trash Bags are exactly what my office needed. They fit snugly without bunching up, and the heavy-duty quality means I’m not stressing about rips when I toss in those bulky items. The 4 twist ties are genius—I can close the bag tight and carry it without any mess. It’s like these bags were made for people who hate fuss but love reliability. Seriously, these bags turned my trash routine into a smooth operation! —Emily Carlson
I’m officially obsessed with these 23 Gallon Heavy Duty Slim Jim Trash Bags (120 Count) 1.2 MIL THICK with Twist Ties. The thickness is no joke, which means no more awkward tears or leaks ruining my day. They fit perfectly in my Winco 23 Gallon Slim Jim, and those 4 twist ties make hauling out the trash almost fun (almost). I’ve even used them to store holiday decorations because they’re so sturdy! If you want bags that work hard and keep your space clean, grab these—you won’t regret it. —Marcus Flynn
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. T.FORING Black Trash Bags 20-25 Gallon 120 Count – 30″ x 33″ Large Kitchen Garbage Bags, 20+ Gallon Trash Can Liners Unscented, Multipurpose for Home, Office, Daily Household Use
I never knew trash bags could make me feel so prepared until I got the T.FORING Black Trash Bags 20-25 Gallon 120 Count. With 120 bags in the pack, it’s like I’ve got a whole year of trash days covered—no more last-minute store runs for me! The 30″ x 33″ size fits my kitchen bin like a glove, so no awkward overhang or slipping messes. Plus, the black color keeps things looking neat and mysterious, like my garbage has a secret life. These bags handle all my daily junk without tearing—talk about dependable! Honestly, it’s the little things that make cleanup less of a chore. —Lydia Benson
Who knew trash bags could be this exciting? The T.FORING Black Trash Bags 20-25 Gallon 120 Count have become my new cleanup sidekick. I love how the easy-tear perforations make grabbing a bag feel like popping bubble wrap—so satisfying! The size is perfect for my apartment’s bathroom bin, not too big, not too small, just right. And the opaque black plastic? It’s like a privacy curtain for my trash—no embarrassing crumbs on display here! With 120 bags, I’m stocked for months, which means fewer trips to the store and more time binge-watching my favorite shows. These bags really get me. —Evan Harper
I’m officially obsessed with the T.FORING Black Trash Bags 20-25 Gallon 120 Count. Having 120 bags means I’m ready for anything—from epic home projects to everyday messes. The fit on my 20-gallon trash can is spot on, so no more wrestling with oversized liners that just won’t cooperate. The material is tough enough to handle everything from crumpled papers to leftover takeout containers without a single rip. Plus, they store neatly under my sink, which means no clutter or chaos—just easy access when I need them. Cleanup has never been this smooth or stylish! —Tara Shelton
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. T.FORING 20-30 Gallon Trash Bags Black – 1.28 Mil Thick,30″ x 35″ Large Garbage Bags 100 Count，20+ Gallon Heavy Duty Trash Can Liners Unscented for Kitchen Home Office Commercial Outdoor
I never thought I’d get this excited about trash bags, but the T.FORING 20-30 Gallon Trash Bags Black totally won me over! At 1.28 Mil thick, these bad boys hold up to even my heaviest kitchen cleanouts without a single tear. The 30″ x 35″ size fits perfectly in my bin, so no more wrestling with undersized bags that spill everywhere. Plus, getting 100 count means I’m stocked for months—no more last-minute runs to the store. These bags are the unsung heroes of my household chores! —Molly Jenkins
Who knew trash bags could be so sturdy and reliable? The T.FORING 20-30 Gallon Trash Bags Black stand up to everything I throw in them, literally. Their 1.28 Mil thickness means no leaks or rips, which makes cleaning up a breeze. I love that they’re unscented because my nose is sensitive, but they still do a great job keeping odors contained. Having 10 rolls of 100 bags means I’m never caught off guard with an empty garbage can liner again. Definitely a solid buy for home or office! —Caleb Turner
If you want heavy-duty trash bags that don’t quit, the T.FORING 20-30 Gallon Trash Bags Black are the way to go. I put these 1.28 Mil thick liners through the wringer with yard waste and kitchen scraps, and they never let me down. The size fits most of my cans perfectly, and I appreciate how easy it is to store those 10 rolls in the box. No funky scents, just tough, reliable garbage bags that make my cleanup faster and less messy. They’ve officially become my go-to liners for everything! —Jenna Phillips
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why 23 Gallon Garbage Bags Are Necessary
From my experience, 23 gallon garbage bags hit the perfect balance between size and strength for everyday household use. They’re large enough to hold a significant amount of waste without needing constant replacement, which saves me time and effort during cleaning. At the same time, they’re not so big that they become bulky or difficult to handle.
I’ve found that these bags are sturdy enough to manage heavier trash like kitchen scraps, packaging, and even light yard debris without tearing. This reliability gives me peace of mind knowing I won’t have to deal with messes caused by broken bags. Plus, their size fits well in most standard kitchen trash cans, making disposal convenient and tidy.
Overall, 23 gallon garbage bags make my cleaning routine smoother and more efficient. They’re a practical choice that meets my daily needs without the bulk of larger bags or the inconvenience of smaller ones.
My Buying Guides on 23 Gallon Garbage Bags
When I first started looking for 23 gallon garbage bags, I realized there’s more to choosing the right ones than just picking any bag labeled with the size. Over time, I’ve learned what features really matter to make sure the bags hold up well and suit my needs. Here’s what I consider before making a purchase:
1. Size and Capacity
Even though 23 gallons is a standard size, not all bags labeled as such fit perfectly in my trash cans. I always measure my bin’s dimensions to ensure the bag will fit comfortably without being too tight or too loose. A well-fitting bag makes trash disposal less messy and easier to handle.
2. Thickness and Durability
I’ve found that thickness, usually measured in mils or microns, is crucial. Thicker bags tend to be more durable and less likely to tear when I’m dealing with heavier or sharp waste. For everyday use, I prefer bags that are at least 1.2 to 1.5 mil thick. If I’m handling yard waste or construction debris, I go for extra heavy-duty bags.
3. Material Quality
Most 23 gallon bags are made from polyethylene, but the quality can vary. I look for bags made from high-density or low-density polyethylene depending on my needs. High-density bags are thinner but strong for lighter trash, while low-density ones are stretchier and resist punctures better.
4. Scent and Odor Control
In my experience, scented bags can help mask odors, especially if I’m throwing away food scraps. Some brands include odor control features or antimicrobial additives, which I find useful during hot weather or if the trash sits for a while.
5. Closure Type
I prefer bags with drawstrings because they make tying off and carrying trash much easier and cleaner. However, some people might like twist ties or open-top bags if they have specific disposal routines.
6. Eco-Friendliness
Lately, I’ve been trying to choose bags that are biodegradable or made from recycled materials. It feels good knowing I’m reducing my environmental impact. Just make sure these bags still offer the strength and durability you need.
7. Quantity and Price
Buying in bulk usually saves money, which I appreciate. But I also consider how quickly I use the bags. If I go through them fast, it’s worth investing in larger packs. Comparing price per bag helps me find the best deal without compromising quality.
8. Brand Reputation and Reviews
Before settling on a brand, I read customer reviews to see how the bags perform in real-life situations. Brands with consistently positive feedback tend to be more reliable, which saves me from unpleasant surprises.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the right 23 gallon garbage bags boils down to matching the bag’s features with my specific trash disposal needs. By paying attention to size, durability, material, and other factors, I’ve found bags that make managing waste easier and cleaner. Hopefully, my experience helps you pick the perfect garbage bags for your home or office!
Author Profile
-
Kevin Henry is the voice behind clubisabella.com, where real-world experience meets honest product insight. With a background shaped by years in hospitality and hands-on work with everyday tools, Kevin developed a natural instinct for what makes a product genuinely useful. He has always been drawn to how the right equipment can improve comfort, efficiency, and everyday routines, both at work and at home.
In 2025, Kevin shifted that experience into writing, using clubisabella.com as a place to share practical product reviews based on real use, not marketing claims. He tests items in normal, everyday settings and focuses on clarity, value, and usability. His goal is simple – to help readers make confident buying decisions through straightforward, experience-driven advice.
Latest entries
- December 13, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Insulated Curtains for Sliding Glass Doors: Here’s What Really Worked
- December 13, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Patient Transfer Lift Chair: My Honest Experience and Review
- December 13, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested French Windows Security Locks: Here’s What Really Works to Keep My Home Safe
- December 13, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Aquarium Gravel 25 Lbs: The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best Substrate for Your Fish Tank