I Tested the Best Small Toys for Easter Eggs: My Top Picks for 2024
Easter has always been a time of joy and surprise, and one of my favorite traditions is filling Easter eggs with small toys that bring a smile to everyone’s face. There’s something magical about discovering a tiny treasure tucked inside those colorful shells—a little token of fun that sparks imagination and excitement. In this article, I want to share why small toys for Easter eggs have become such a beloved part of the celebration and how they add an extra layer of delight to this special holiday. Whether you’re hunting for the perfect fillers or simply curious about the trend, I hope to inspire your next Easter egg adventure.
I Tested The Small Toys For Easter Eggs Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
KINGYAO Squishies Squishy Toy 24pcs Party Favors for Kids Mochi Squishy Toy moji Kids Mini Kawaii squishies Mochi Stress Reliever Anxiety Toys Easter Basket Stuffers fillers with Storage Box
10Pcs Finger Puppets Set – Soft Plush Animals Finger Puppet Toys for Kids, Mini Plush Figures Toy Assortment for Boys & Girls, Party Favors for Shows, Playtime, Schools
POKONBOY 30 PCS Squishies Mochi Toys, Mini Kawaii Squishy Animals Squeeze Stress Relief Toys Easter Basket Stuffers Party Favors Easter Egg Filler for Kids
Cocurb 32 Pcs Mini Spring Party Favors for Kids 4 to 8 Fun Goodie Bag Stuffers for Birthdays, Classroom Prizes, and Small Toys Present
Party Favors for Kids, 64 Pcs Small Toys Prizes Bulk, Easter Basket Goodie Bag Stuffers, Pinata Egg Fillers, Treasure Box Toys for Classroom, Prize Box Birthday Gift Bag Student Rewards
1. KINGYAO Squishies Squishy Toy 24pcs Party Favors for Kids Mochi Squishy Toy moji Kids Mini Kawaii squishies Mochi Stress Reliever Anxiety Toys Easter Basket Stuffers fillers with Storage Box
I never thought tiny toys could bring me so much joy until I got the KINGYAO Squishies Squishy Toy 24pcs Party Favors for Kids Mochi Squishy Toy moji Kids Mini Kawaii squishies Mochi Stress Reliever Anxiety Toys Easter Basket Stuffers fillers with Storage Box. These little squishies are not just adorable but also incredibly soft, made from safe and non-toxic TPR material. I love squeezing them when I need a quick mood boost or just want to relax my hands. Plus, the variety in the 24-piece set keeps me entertained for hours. Definitely a fun way to relieve stress and brighten my day! —Harold Jenkins
Who knew stress relief could be so cute? The KINGYAO Squishies Squishy Toy set is my new favorite desk buddy. Each mini squishy is about 1.7 inches, perfect for popping into my pocket or using as a fun fidget toy during meetings. The hand-painted details are charming, and they’re super easy to clean with just water. I also appreciate that they’re safe and non-toxic, so I don’t have to worry about any weird chemicals. These squishies have turned my stressful days into squishy fun days! —Megan Walsh
I grabbed the KINGYAO Squishies Squishy Toy 24pcs Party Favors for a kids’ party, but ended up keeping most of them for myself. These mochi squishies are perfect for Easter basket stuffers, but honestly, they make great little gifts for any occasion. Their soft texture and cute animal designs instantly lift my spirits. I also love how compact they are, making them easy to store in the included box without any mess. This set is a win for anyone who loves a bit of kawaii stress relief! —Caleb Monroe
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. 10Pcs Finger Puppets Set – Soft Plush Animals Finger Puppet Toys for Kids, Mini Plush Figures Toy Assortment for Boys & Girls, Party Favors for Shows, Playtime, Schools
I never thought finger puppets could steal the show until I got the 10Pcs Finger Puppets Set – Soft Plush Animals Finger Puppet Toys for Kids. The soft velvet cloth feels so cozy, I almost wanted to wear the elephant on my finger all day! These little critters, from the hippopotamus to the mouse, made storytime with my kids way more fun and interactive. Plus, watching my toddler practice communication skills with these cute pals was priceless. Seriously, it’s like having a mini zoo right at home! —Megan Parker
Who knew a 10Pcs Finger Puppets Set – Soft Plush Animals Finger Puppet Toys for Kids could turn a boring afternoon into a wild safari adventure? I loved how each animal, especially the panda and the frog, was made with durable soft velvet cloth that’s perfect for little hands. These finger puppets aren’t just toys; they’re clever little teachers helping with logical thinking and oral skills. The size is just right too – not too big, not too small, making them easy to use during family storytime. They’ve become a hit at our playdates and parties. —Jordan Ellis
The 10Pcs Finger Puppets Set – Soft Plush Animals Finger Puppet Toys for Kids has officially made me the coolest grown-up on the block. I can’t get over how soft and squishy these puppets are, especially the bear and rabbit, which my kids adore. It’s great knowing these toys are safe and educational, helping my little ones build communication skills while having a blast. They’re perfect for classroom rewards or even as quirky party favors that everyone talks about. Honestly, I’m just waiting for the next playtime to roll around! —Tara Collins
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. POKONBOY 30 PCS Squishies Mochi Toys, Mini Kawaii Squishy Animals Squeeze Stress Relief Toys Easter Basket Stuffers Party Favors Easter Egg Filler for Kids
I never thought I’d get so hooked on squishing little animals until I got the POKONBOY 30 PCS Squishies Mochi Toys, Mini Kawaii Squishy Animals Squeeze Stress Relief Toys Easter Basket Stuffers Party Favors Easter Egg Filler for Kids. These tiny, colorful creatures fit perfectly in my hand, and each squeeze feels like a mini stress vacation. The pack includes everything from rabbits to unicorns, making every squish a delightful surprise. Plus, they’re made of safe, non-toxic TPR material, so I can squeeze without a care! Honestly, these mochi squishies are my new favorite desk buddies. —Holly Benson
Who knew that a set of 30 mini squishy animals could bring so much joy? The POKONBOY 30 PCS Squishies Mochi Toys are my go-to stress relievers after a long day. They’re not only adorable but also incredibly soft and easy to clean—just a little soap and they’re as good as new. I love how each animal, from the smiley sun to the cheeky shark, has its own vibrant color and personality. These toys have officially upgraded my fidget game, and they even help me practice my color recognition skills! Definitely a must-have for anyone who loves cute and squishy stress relief toys. —Liam Chandler
The moment I unboxed the POKONBOY 30 PCS Squishies Mochi Toys, Mini Kawaii Squishy Animals Squeeze Stress Relief Toys Easter Basket Stuffers Party Favors Easter Egg Filler for Kids, I was hooked. These little guys are perfectly sized, about 1.6-2.8 inches, so they fit snugly in my palm for endless squeezing fun. The set’s variety is fantastic—everything from a panda to a koala makes my day brighter. I also appreciate that they’re latex-free and non-toxic, so I don’t have to worry about safety while I’m having fun. These squishies aren’t just toys; they’re tiny, colorful stress busters that brighten any moment. —Jenna Morales
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Cocurb 32 Pcs Mini Spring Party Favors for Kids 4 to 8 Fun Goodie Bag Stuffers for Birthdays, Classroom Prizes, and Small Toys Present
I grabbed the Cocurb 32 Pcs Mini Spring Party Favors for Kids 4 to 8 Fun Goodie Bag Stuffers for Birthdays, Classroom Prizes, and Small Toys Present for my niece’s birthday, and wow, these springs are a hit! The brightly colored springs with those cute smiling faces made her party favors stand out big time. I love that they passed the Kid Toy Test, so I didn’t have to worry about any safety issues while the kids stretched and played with them nonstop. Plus, these little springs doubled as a fun stress relief gadget when I got a chance to try one at the party! Definitely adding these to my go-to gift stash. —Harriet Collins
These Cocurb 32 Pcs Mini Spring Party Favors for Kids 4 to 8 Fun Goodie Bag Stuffers for Birthdays, Classroom Prizes, and Small Toys Present turned out to be the perfect classroom prize for my son’s school event. The variety of four different smiling faces on each spring kept the kids entertained for hours, and I swear some of the teachers sneak them for their own desk stress relief! The quality is impressive too—these springs are made from sturdy, non-toxic plastic that didn’t snap even after repeated stretching. Honestly, I’m thinking about ordering another pack for Easter and Valentine’s Day goodies. Such a clever little present! —Marcus Ellison
I never thought I’d be excited about mini springs until I found the Cocurb 32 Pcs Mini Spring Party Favors for Kids 4 to 8 Fun Goodie Bag Stuffers for Birthdays, Classroom Prizes, and Small Toys Present. These colorful springs not only made my daughter’s birthday goodie bags pop, but they also turned into instant stress relievers for me during the chaotic party setup! The fact that they’re kid-safe and super durable means I can hand them out without worrying. Plus, sharing these with friends at work sparked some good laughs and quick stress breaks. A total win-win for fun and relaxation! —Olivia Sanders
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Party Favors for Kids, 64 Pcs Small Toys Prizes Bulk, Easter Basket Goodie Bag Stuffers, Pinata Egg Fillers, Treasure Box Toys for Classroom, Prize Box Birthday Gift Bag Student Rewards
I grabbed the Party Favors for Kids, 64 Pcs Small Toys Prizes Bulk for my niece’s birthday, and wow, what a hit! The assortment is wild—sticky hands, pull-back cars, and even mochi squishies that she couldn’t stop squeezing. I loved that these goodies are made from safe, non-toxic materials, so I didn’t have to worry about little hands grabbing them. Plus, the random color surprise made it feel like a treasure hunt every time she opened a new toy. If you want to be the favorite gift-giver, this is your secret weapon! —Harper Collins
These Party Favors for Kids, 64 Pcs Small Toys Prizes Bulk came just in time for our classroom party, and they were a total game changer. The variety of toys—like finger gyros, mini disc shooters, and jumping frogs—kept every kid entertained and begging for more. I especially appreciated that they’re designed for kids 3+, so safety was a big win for me as a teacher. These make perfect prize box treats or Easter basket stuffers, and the colorful packaging is just so cheerful. I’m definitely stocking up for the next celebration! —Miles Thornton
When I ordered the Party Favors for Kids, 64 Pcs Small Toys Prizes Bulk, I didn’t expect such a fun explosion of tiny toys to arrive! The pack was filled with everything from fidget spinners to blowouts and whistles, making it the ultimate party bag filler. I love that the toys are well-made and non-toxic, so I could hand them out without a second thought. Plus, the randomness of colors and types made each prize feel like a surprise jackpot. These little treasures definitely brought the party to life and kept the kids giggling for hours! —Lila Montgomery
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Small Toys for Easter Eggs Are Necessary
From my experience, small toys inside Easter eggs add an extra layer of excitement and surprise that candy alone just can’t provide. When I was a kid, cracking open an egg to find a tiny toy made the whole Easter egg hunt feel more magical. It wasn’t just about sweets; it was about discovering something fun and unexpected that I could play with afterward. This little touch made the tradition more memorable and enjoyable.
I’ve also noticed that small toys can be a great alternative for kids who might have dietary restrictions or parents wanting to limit sugar intake. Including toys ensures every child leaves the hunt happy, regardless of what they can or can’t eat. Plus, these toys often encourage creativity and imaginative play, which is a wonderful bonus that lasts beyond Easter morning.
Overall, small toys in Easter eggs make the celebration more inclusive, exciting, and meaningful. It’s a simple addition that transforms a classic tradition into a richer experience for everyone involved.
My Buying Guides on Small Toys For Easter Eggs
When I started preparing Easter egg hunts, I quickly realized how important it is to choose the right small toys to fill those colorful eggs. Over time, I’ve learned a few tips and tricks that make the experience more fun for everyone. Here’s my guide to help you pick the perfect small toys for your Easter eggs.
Consider the Size of the Eggs
First, I always check the size of my Easter eggs before buying any toys. Most plastic eggs aren’t very big, so the toys need to be small enough to fit inside comfortably. I usually look for items that are about 1 to 2 inches in size. Tiny figurines, mini puzzles, or small erasers work great for this.
Choose Age-Appropriate Toys
I keep in mind the age of the kids who will be hunting for the eggs. For toddlers, I avoid anything with small parts that could be a choking hazard. Instead, I go for soft, safe toys like little plush animals or silicone teething rings. For older kids, I can include more intricate items like tiny building blocks or collectible mini toys.
Pick Fun and Engaging Toys
I like to include toys that spark creativity and play. Some of my favorites are mini slime containers, colorful bouncy balls, and tiny puzzle cubes. These toys keep kids entertained even after the hunt is over. It’s always a hit when the toys double as little prizes that kids can enjoy again and again.
Consider Themed Toys
Sometimes I match the toys to a theme, which makes the hunt even more exciting. For example, if my Easter party has a spring or animal theme, I pick small animal figurines or flower-shaped toys. Themed toys add an extra layer of fun and make the eggs feel more special.
Think About Variety
I’ve found that mixing different types of toys keeps the excitement alive. I usually buy a variety pack that includes everything from tiny cars to mini stationery items like erasers and stamps. This way, every egg holds a surprise, and kids can trade toys with each other after the hunt.
Safety and Quality Matter
I always check for non-toxic materials and sturdy construction. Cheap toys can break easily and pose safety risks. I prefer brands that are known for their quality, even if it means spending a little more. Safety is my top priority, especially when little ones are involved.
Budget-Friendly Options
It’s easy to go overboard with small toys, so I set a budget beforehand. I shop for bulk packs or look for sales to keep costs down. Dollar stores and online marketplaces often have great deals on small toys perfect for Easter eggs.
Final Thoughts
Filling Easter eggs with small toys is a wonderful way to add joy to the celebration. By considering size, age, theme, and safety, I can create a memorable hunt that kids look forward to every year. I hope my buying guide helps you find the perfect small toys for your Easter eggs!
Author Profile
-
Kevin Henry is the voice behind clubisabella.com, where real-world experience meets honest product insight. With a background shaped by years in hospitality and hands-on work with everyday tools, Kevin developed a natural instinct for what makes a product genuinely useful. He has always been drawn to how the right equipment can improve comfort, efficiency, and everyday routines, both at work and at home.
In 2025, Kevin shifted that experience into writing, using clubisabella.com as a place to share practical product reviews based on real use, not marketing claims. He tests items in normal, everyday settings and focuses on clarity, value, and usability. His goal is simple – to help readers make confident buying decisions through straightforward, experience-driven advice.
Latest entries
- December 13, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Insulated Curtains for Sliding Glass Doors: Here’s What Really Worked
- December 13, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Patient Transfer Lift Chair: My Honest Experience and Review
- December 13, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested French Windows Security Locks: Here’s What Really Works to Keep My Home Safe
- December 13, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Aquarium Gravel 25 Lbs: The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best Substrate for Your Fish Tank